Implement strategies#

The strategy abstraction enables implementation of fully custom strategies. A strategy is basically the federated learning algorithm that runs on the server. Strategies decide how to sample clients, how to configure clients for training, how to aggregate updates, and how to evaluate models. Flower provides a few built-in strategies which are based on the same API described below.

The `Strategy` abstraction#

All strategy implementation are derived from the abstract base class flwr.server.strategy.Strategy, both built-in implementations and third party implementations. This means that custom strategy implementations have the exact same capabilities at their disposal as built-in ones.

The strategy abstraction defines a few abstract methods that need to be implemented:

class Strategy(ABC):
    """Abstract base class for server strategy implementations."""

    @abstractmethod
    def initialize_parameters(
        self, client_manager: ClientManager
    ) -> Optional[Parameters]:
        """Initialize the (global) model parameters."""

    @abstractmethod
    def configure_fit(
        self,
        server_round: int,
        parameters: Parameters,
        client_manager: ClientManager
    ) -> List[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitIns]]:
        """Configure the next round of training."""

    @abstractmethod
    def aggregate_fit(
        self,
        server_round: int,
        results: List[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitRes]],
        failures: List[Union[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitRes], BaseException]],
    ) -> Tuple[Optional[Parameters], Dict[str, Scalar]]:
        """Aggregate training results."""

    @abstractmethod
    def configure_evaluate(
        self,
        server_round: int,
        parameters: Parameters,
        client_manager: ClientManager
    ) -> List[Tuple[ClientProxy, EvaluateIns]]:
        """Configure the next round of evaluation."""

    @abstractmethod
    def aggregate_evaluate(
        self,
        server_round: int,
        results: List[Tuple[ClientProxy, EvaluateRes]],
        failures: List[Union[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitRes], BaseException]],
    ) -> Tuple[Optional[float], Dict[str, Scalar]]:
        """Aggregate evaluation results."""

    @abstractmethod
    def evaluate(
        self, parameters: Parameters
    ) -> Optional[Tuple[float, Dict[str, Scalar]]]:
        """Evaluate the current model parameters."""

Creating a new strategy means implementing a new class (derived from the abstract base class Strategy) that implements for the previously shown abstract methods:

class SotaStrategy(Strategy):
    def initialize_parameters(self, client_manager):
        # Your implementation here

    def configure_fit(self, server_round, parameters, client_manager):
        # Your implementation here

    def aggregate_fit(self, server_round, results, failures):
        # Your implementation here

    def configure_evaluate(self, server_round, parameters, client_manager):
        # Your implementation here

    def aggregate_evaluate(self, server_round, results, failures):
        # Your implementation here

    def evaluate(self, parameters):
        # Your implementation here

The Flower server calls these methods in the following order:

sequenceDiagram participant Strategy participant S as Flower Server start_server participant C1 as Flower Client participant C2 as Flower Client Note left of S: Get initial model parameters S->>Strategy: initialize_parameters activate Strategy Strategy-->>S: Parameters deactivate Strategy Note left of S: Federated Training rect rgb(249, 219, 130) S->>Strategy: configure_fit activate Strategy Strategy-->>S: List[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitIns]] deactivate Strategy S->>C1: FitIns activate C1 S->>C2: FitIns activate C2 C1-->>S: FitRes deactivate C1 C2-->>S: FitRes deactivate C2 S->>Strategy: aggregate_fit List[FitRes] activate Strategy Strategy-->>S: Aggregated model parameters deactivate Strategy end Note left of S: Centralized Evaluation rect rgb(249, 219, 130) S->>Strategy: evaluate activate Strategy Strategy-->>S: Centralized evaluation result deactivate Strategy end Note left of S: Federated Evaluation rect rgb(249, 219, 130) S->>Strategy: configure_evaluate activate Strategy Strategy-->>S: List[Tuple[ClientProxy, EvaluateIns]] deactivate Strategy S->>C1: EvaluateIns activate C1 S->>C2: EvaluateIns activate C2 C1-->>S: EvaluateRes deactivate C1 C2-->>S: EvaluateRes deactivate C2 S->>Strategy: aggregate_evaluate List[EvaluateRes] activate Strategy Strategy-->>S: Aggregated evaluation results deactivate Strategy end Note left of S: Next round, continue with federated training

The following sections describe each of those methods in more detail.

The `initialize_parameters` method#

initialize_parameters is called only once, at the very beginning of an execution. It is responsible for providing the initial global model parameters in a serialized form (i.e., as a Parameters object).

Built-in strategies return user-provided initial parameters. The following example shows how initial parameters can be passed to FedAvg:

import flwr as fl
import tensorflow as tf

# Load model for server-side parameter initialization
model = tf.keras.applications.EfficientNetB0(
    input_shape=(32, 32, 3), weights=None, classes=10
)
model.compile("adam", "sparse_categorical_crossentropy", metrics=["accuracy"])

# Get model weights as a list of NumPy ndarray's
weights = model.get_weights()

# Serialize ndarrays to `Parameters`
parameters = fl.common.ndarrays_to_parameters(weights)

# Use the serialized parameters as the initial global parameters
strategy = fl.server.strategy.FedAvg(
    initial_parameters=parameters,
)
fl.server.start_server(config=fl.server.ServerConfig(num_rounds=3), strategy=strategy)

The Flower server will call initialize_parameters, which either returns the parameters that were passed to initial_parameters, or None. If no parameters are returned from initialize_parameters (i.e., None), the server will randomly select one client and ask it to provide its parameters. This is a convenience feature and not recommended in practice, but it can be useful for prototyping. In practice, it is recommended to always use server-side parameter initialization.

Note

Server-side parameter initialization is a powerful mechanism. It can be used, for example, to resume training from a previously saved checkpoint. It is also the fundamental capability needed to implement hybrid approaches, for example, to fine-tune a pre-trained model using federated learning.

The `configure_fit` method#

configure_fit is responsible for configuring the upcoming round of training. What does configure mean in this context? Configuring a round means selecting clients and deciding what instructions to send to these clients. The signature of configure_fit makes this clear:

@abstractmethod
def configure_fit(
    self,
    server_round: int,
    parameters: Parameters,
    client_manager: ClientManager
) -> List[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitIns]]:
    """Configure the next round of training."""

The return value is a list of tuples, each representing the instructions that will be sent to a particular client. Strategy implementations usually perform the following steps in configure_fit:

Use the client_manager to randomly sample all (or a subset of) available clients (each represented as a ClientProxy object)
Pair each ClientProxy with the same FitIns holding the current global model parameters and config dict

More sophisticated implementations can use configure_fit to implement custom client selection logic. A client will only participate in a round if the corresponding ClientProxy is included in the list returned from configure_fit.

Note

The structure of this return value provides a lot of flexibility to the user. Since instructions are defined on a per-client basis, different instructions can be sent to each client. This enables custom strategies to train, for example, different models on different clients, or use different hyperparameters on different clients (via the config dict).

The `aggregate_fit` method#

aggregate_fit is responsible for aggregating the results returned by the clients that were selected and asked to train in configure_fit.

@abstractmethod
def aggregate_fit(
    self,
    server_round: int,
    results: List[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitRes]],
    failures: List[Union[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitRes], BaseException]],
) -> Tuple[Optional[Parameters], Dict[str, Scalar]]:
    """Aggregate training results."""

Of course, failures can happen, so there is no guarantee that the server will get results from all the clients it sent instructions to (via configure_fit). aggregate_fit therefore receives a list of results, but also a list of failures.

aggregate_fit returns an optional Parameters object and a dictionary of aggregated metrics. The Parameters return value is optional because aggregate_fit might decide that the results provided are not sufficient for aggregation (e.g., too many failures).

The `configure_evaluate` method#

configure_evaluate is responsible for configuring the upcoming round of evaluation. What does configure mean in this context? Configuring a round means selecting clients and deciding what instructions to send to these clients. The signature of configure_evaluate makes this clear:

@abstractmethod
def configure_evaluate(
    self,
    server_round: int,
    parameters: Parameters,
    client_manager: ClientManager
) -> List[Tuple[ClientProxy, EvaluateIns]]:
    """Configure the next round of evaluation."""

The return value is a list of tuples, each representing the instructions that will be sent to a particular client. Strategy implementations usually perform the following steps in configure_evaluate:

Use the client_manager to randomly sample all (or a subset of) available clients (each represented as a ClientProxy object)
Pair each ClientProxy with the same EvaluateIns holding the current global model parameters and config dict

More sophisticated implementations can use configure_evaluate to implement custom client selection logic. A client will only participate in a round if the corresponding ClientProxy is included in the list returned from configure_evaluate.

Note

The structure of this return value provides a lot of flexibility to the user. Since instructions are defined on a per-client basis, different instructions can be sent to each client. This enables custom strategies to evaluate, for example, different models on different clients, or use different hyperparameters on different clients (via the config dict).

The `aggregate_evaluate` method#

aggregate_evaluate is responsible for aggregating the results returned by the clients that were selected and asked to evaluate in configure_evaluate.

@abstractmethod
def aggregate_evaluate(
    self,
    server_round: int,
    results: List[Tuple[ClientProxy, EvaluateRes]],
    failures: List[Union[Tuple[ClientProxy, FitRes], BaseException]],
) -> Tuple[Optional[float], Dict[str, Scalar]]:
    """Aggregate evaluation results."""

Of course, failures can happen, so there is no guarantee that the server will get results from all the clients it sent instructions to (via configure_evaluate). aggregate_evaluate therefore receives a list of results, but also a list of failures.

aggregate_evaluate returns an optional float (loss) and a dictionary of aggregated metrics. The float return value is optional because aggregate_evaluate might decide that the results provided are not sufficient for aggregation (e.g., too many failures).

The `evaluate` method#

evaluate is responsible for evaluating model parameters on the server-side. Having evaluate in addition to configure_evaluate/aggregate_evaluate enables strategies to perform both servers-side and client-side (federated) evaluation.

@abstractmethod
def evaluate(
    self, parameters: Parameters
) -> Optional[Tuple[float, Dict[str, Scalar]]]:
    """Evaluate the current model parameters."""

The return value is again optional because the strategy might not need to implement server-side evaluation or because the user-defined evaluate method might not complete successfully (e.g., it might fail to load the server-side evaluation data).

Implement strategies#

The Strategy abstraction#

The initialize_parameters method#

The configure_fit method#

The aggregate_fit method#

The configure_evaluate method#

The aggregate_evaluate method#

The evaluate method#

The `Strategy` abstraction#

The `initialize_parameters` method#

The `configure_fit` method#

The `aggregate_fit` method#

The `configure_evaluate` method#

The `aggregate_evaluate` method#

The `evaluate` method#